‘Play Dirty’: Shane Black On Reinventing Parker, Mark Wahlberg Stepping In For Robert Downey Jr. & Much More [The Discourse Podcast]

The underworld is crowded with thieves, but Parker has always stood apart. Created by Donald Westlake in the early 1960s, the character has been portrayed on screen by actors including Lee Marvin, Mel Gibson, and Jason Statham. He’s a blunt-force professional who isn’t Bond, isn’t Batman, but something rougher, hungrier, and coded by his own ruthless blue-collar sense of order. With “Play Dirty”, filmmaker Shane Black takes his own crack at Parker, bringing him to Prime Video on October 1 and putting Mark Wahlberg in the role. The film follows Parker, a ruthless thief, and his expert crew who stumble onto the heist of a lifetime that pits them against the New York mob. The film also stars LaKeith Stanfield, Rosa Salazar, Keegan-Michael Key, Nat Wolff, and more. 

READ MORE: ‘All Of You’: Brett Goldstein On Love, The Science of Soulmates, ‘Shrinking’ Surprises, & ‘Ted Lasso’ [The Discourse Podcast]

This version doesn’t come with gadgets or acrobatics. Black describes a Parker who thinks fast, hits harder, and feels closer to the blue-collar world than to the spy fantasy. It’s the kind of material that lets him indulge his taste for pulp grit, sly humor, and the holiday backdrop he’s made famous. But it also opens the door to some bigger questions: what draws audiences to men this uncompromising? How do you make crime fun without sanding off the edges? And what happens when you cast Wahlberg instead of Robert Downey Jr.?

Writer/Director Shane Black joins The Discourse to discuss the journey of bringing his Parker film to the screen, which began during the making of Black’s first film, “Kiss Kiss Bang Bang,” in 2005. When asked what itch hadn’t been scratched by earlier adaptations, Black pointed to Parker’s uniqueness. “Each one represents the era in which it was produced. ‘Point Blank’ with Lee Marvin is a very specific film for that time period. And each actor who’s played Parker from there on, like Robert Duvall, Jason Statham, and Mel Gibson in “Payback.” There has been a history of incarnations of this powerful, relentless character. But he’s not James Bond, which is why I liked him. He’s blue-collar. It’s almost like an American entrepreneur’s story. But he happens to be a really awful, bad person and a criminal anti-hero.”

While the film was initially announced with Robert Downey Jr. attached to play Parker, Downey opted to produce instead, leaving the role open for another to step in. Enter Mark Wahlberg, who Black says brought fresh energy. “By the way, Mark Wahlberg, given a chance to play this character, that’s part of the attraction too, for me. He’s the guy I described. You get a new iteration. This is a version that you say, ‘Okay, let’s see what this one looks like!’ And I think if you’ve seen the film, Mark shows up, he brings it.”

But what exactly happened with RDJ, Black’s longtime collaborator? “There was talk of [Downey being Parker]. He stayed on as producer of the film with his company, Team Downey, and his wife, Susan, as well as the other producer, Jules Daly. That sort of stuff happens. I guess he’s off playing Dr. Doom, and I can’t wait to see that. However, he has remained steadfast in his support for the project in the future. And Mark was there. Mark stepped up. A project becomes available, and he said, I like this material, and just snapped at it.”

One of the perennial questions around Black is tone: his films often marry sharp edges with a playful sense of mischief. That balance applies here as well. “We don’t compromise on Parker’s character. It’s hard, edgy. There is a sort of wry quality to the Parker books. They’re not comedies. In fact, Westlake wrote a whole series of comic novels, and then he wrote Parker, which is sort of the other side of that coin. It’s darker, grittier, cynical. But there’s still a lot of wry humor because that’s who that writer was. I think it’s possible to give a little nod to the comic side of Westlake without compromising Parker, because ultimately these books were supposed to be fun.”

And yes, Black once again sets the story during Christmas, a classic Shane Black setting. “I didn’t want to necessarily do it for this movie, but I did want to set it in New York in the winter. Christmas provides me just a sort of hush, a halt in the progress of things, where lonely people feel lonelier. The outcasts of society look in the window and see other people enjoying the Christmas season. They see shoppers going by. They see people who have an implicit knowledge of how to enjoy a holiday. That’s a memo our character didn’t get. It makes an arena where everyone has something in common, and the city at Christmastime becomes the backdrop. It almost becomes a character.”

Support independent movie journalism to keep it alive. Sign up for The Playlist Newsletter. All the content you want and, oh, right, it’s free.

“Play Dirty” arrives on Prime Video on October 1. Listen to the whole conversation with Shane Black below:

The Discourse is part of The Playlist Podcast Network, which includes Deep Focus, Bingeworthy, and more. We can be heard on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Soundcloud, and most places where podcasts are found. You can stream the podcast via the embed within the article.. Be sure to subscribe and drop us a comment or a rating, as we greatly appreciate it. Thank you for listening.

The Playlist Presents: Shane Black’s Film & TV Recommendation Playlist:

• “Dept Q” (Netflix)
• “The Queen’s Gambit” (Netflix)
• “Godless” (Netflix)
• “Dark” (Netflix)

Mike DeAngelo

+ postsBio ⮌

This author does not have any more posts